Typos, Mistakes?


Gregorius
Gregorius's picture

Hi, these might be some inadvertent mistakes...

Initiative on Skills table (Skills 7) has sunsign modifier Ahn/Ang/Nad +1, but on Glossdex 19 it says: "There is no astrological modifier."

On combat tables under Armor Protective Values if you add Ring & Cloth you should get B2 E6 P1 F4 S1 T5, but under Combinations Chart its listed as B3 E7 P2 F6 S1 T6. It seems that the Ring+Leather combination was accidentally used in its place. I believe this error extends down to the generic armor profiles. Under armor Light(I) a Ring half helm and Cloth cowl are giving B3 E7 P2 protection to skull (too high), the same protection value is given to Medium (A)armor whenever Ring+Cloth coincide and this might be found in other places too.

An asterisk (*) denotes that Point Aspect is optional and, if included, reduces basic Weapon Quality by one (1)on the weapons data tables. Handaxe and Warhammer both had point as optional in HM1 and HM3 has this changed under HMG or was this accidentally left off?

Players edition mentions Chivalric weapons under Combat 1, but does not inform you what these are and neither does the Weapon Data Tables. It does seem to be found in the GMs edition under a treasure table for weapons. I of course know which are Chivalric, but a new player or GM to Harn might find it useful if listed in Players edition on Combat tables.

Thank you for your time, I hope I was not too nitpicky.

-Greg

Severin
Severin's picture

HMG - References to Frame -Nit

On Character Generation 6 - the Frame Interpretation table on the sidebar - refers to Scant, Light, Medium, Heavy, Massive

On Character Generation 9 - the Agility Modification table on the sidebar - refers to Large frame.

That might be a typo.

Severin
Severin's picture

HMG - Potential Errata/Feedback/Questions

Do you want more of this kind of thing posted here?

Fástred
Fástred's picture

We are happy for this to be posted here

We are happy for this to be posted here, but you can also email me directly at 'jeremy@kelestia.com' if you would prefer.

Regards and thanks

Jeremy

Severin
Severin's picture

When to use Encumbrance Penalties

1. Does Physical Penalty include encumbrance modifiers?

2. "Physical & Combat Skills
These skills are based on physical and sensory attributes and are all
subject to PHYSICAL PENALTY and (if the rule is in force) ENCUMBRANCE" (Skills 6)."
Does that mean that mean Encumbrance is applied to Condition in shock rolls?

3. Regaining Consciousness
"An unconscious character tests CONDITION (subject to PHYSICAL PENALTY) on each subsequent turn"(Glossdex 33). Would Encumbrance penalties apply to my roll to regain consciousness?

Severin
Severin's picture

Knockback - Clarification

Advanced Combat Rule: "A character struck to the body,
head or neck with an Impact in excess of Strength , is
knocked back one hex. A character who is knocked back
makes a STUMBLE ROLL. A knockback of a mounted
character unhorses her/him. See UNHORSING."

So is this Effective Impact (after Armor) or normal Impact (before armor reduction)?

cyrion
cyrion's picture

Try to answer

Hello Severin,

1. No, Physical Penalty is the sum of injury and fatigue penalty. Me think bcause Ecumbrance is an option it was not taken into the Physical Penalty.
2. Yes. Condition is a physical Skill, so if Encumbrance is in effect it is deducted from Condition if you must test the skill.
3. Yes ...
to 2. and 3.
from the rulebook the Encumbrance is substrated from Condition, but if I am laying on the ground how should my equipment bother me. In my group we do not deduct Encumbrance from condition to regain consciousness. I used this in my group if someone needs to be awaken from sleep or so.
We use the old shockrole system from Hârnmaster 1st ED. with 2 - 5 d6 and the Endurance Index.

Knockback:
I use the whole Impact to decide knockbacks and the effective Impact to see for the damage done to PC or NPC. Me think the armour doesn't prevent to be hit, so the full Impact can drive me back. But the armour reduce the Impact for damage.

Hope it will help you.

Cyrion
PS @Jeremy just a typo: in the Bookmark of the Player Edition is Sindârin not replaced with Sinái

Gregorius
Gregorius's picture

Need some clarity

1. ENC.
I too would like to see some clarification on the Encumbrance issue. In the Glossdex it says Condition is subject to Physical Penalty. But it does not mention Encumbrance. If Enc does apply I would like to see it said under Condition and Shock that if this optional rule is in play it does apply.

On the other hand to muddle things up some more in the Glossdex it states under Encumbrance that:

"A heavily encumbered character is less able to perform certain physical actions such as running, jumping or fighting."

If we are nit-picky it does say "certain physical actions" not all, so maybe it does not apply to condition or shock?

Personally I don't think Encumbrance should apply to shock rolls.

2. Knockback.
In HM3 knockback was effective damage (after reducing for armor). This seems to make it more difficult to knock someone back with a very light weapon that by itself does little damage. So if someone stabs a knight's Plate helm with a Taburi/knife they are less likely to knock him back. Instead it would require a heavier and maybe bigger weapon like a Maul or Battle Axe to increase the odds of knockback.

I may be wrong but it seems that if its not effective damage, but normal damage then it would be easier (not easy just easier) to knock people back with light weapons or even a fist to the Knights Plate helm. This maybe how its intended and designed, but again I might like a little clarity especially for someone like me who is moving from HM3 to HMG. A simple line stating that its the damage before armor reduction not after would help.

cyrion
cyrion's picture

Clarity

Hey Gregorius,

1. It is a matter of likeness.
In the Playerediton is written:

"Physical & Combat Skills
These skills are based on physical and sensory attributes and are all
subject to PHYSICAL PENALTY and (if the rule is in force) ENCUMBRANCE."

Condition is a physical skill, so Encumbrance has to be subtracted.
But is a shock role the same as a role on Dodge or Acrobatic. It might be a not just physical to resist the shock.

2. Knockback
I have an example from the time I start my HMG Group. We consider to take the effictive impact, when one of my player said:

"OK, I'm Mr. Notsogood Knight and I'm not very strong. Now I stand here and wear my good quilt, mail and plate layers of armour.
Someone hits me with his ugly sword, brrrr.
OK. I am knockbacked because I am weak, but I am not damaged because I wear my nice and big armour."

So we calculate first if some is knockbacked(*is this written the right way, or how should I write it? not sure;-)*)then we see if he is damaged.

my 2 pence
Cyrion

edit a few typos

Oz
Oz's picture

Some errors, maybe?

Hi all!

I only recently found HMG and frankly it seems to me one of the best RPG ever made: too bad that I don't have discovered it before (but, you know, it is better late than never!).

Okay, let's come to the point: I think I found a couple of typos/mistakes, but I'm learning now the rules and I could be wrong:

1) Player Edition → Combat 20 → Weapon Damage Variants → Option 2 → the optional rule states that "As for Option 3", but I think it meant Option 1 (or not?).

2) Player Edition → Physician 3 → Contagion Roll → ...whether a character catches a disease test Condition + ([CI – 3] x 5), but at Glossdex 10 it says Condition – (CI x 5): well, I'm little confused!

I found also some little errors (mainly punctuation errors), but they're totally harmless.

Thanks in advance for your help and have fun!

Balesir
Balesir's picture

Errata in HMG 2.1

Hi, Oz,

On your first point, it should read "Option 1", correct.

On diseases: my guess is that you could make those three separate options! Option (1): Condition - (CI x 5), or (2): Condition - ([CI-3] x 5) or (3): Endurance x CI. The three will give different lethalities (generally 3 would be most lethal, then 2, with 1 least lethal) to suit your tastes for your p-Harn.

Disease is always a tricky thing to model "well". It relies on characters being exposed to appropriate vectors, when the character most likely has no idea what those vectors are... As always, with Harn, choose your seasoning to taste!

Cheers!

kevsurp
kevsurp's picture

Players guide armor typo

under quilt shirt it list "Ua Sh Tx Ab" as protection areas
but in the premade armor Light F it adds HP and GR it also list arms area which i get as its says it with sleeves but why add hip and groin

Ken
Ken's picture

thanks for the notice! We'll

thanks for the notice! We'll work on getting corrections.


User login










Recent comments




Keléstia Connect





Who's online?

There are currently 0 users and 52 guests online.



© 2014 Keléstia Productions Ltd. and N. Robin Crossby (1954-2008).
The opinions expressed on this website are those of their respective owners and do not necessarily reflect the views of Keléstia Productions Ltd.
Trademarks are the property of their respective owners.